Home

What Is Panchmel Dal and Which Lentils Go into It?

Panchmel dal is a savoury dish of five dals cooked together and finished with a spiced tempering, usually made with ghee. A common combination uses chana, toor, moong, masoor and urad dal. Together, they give you a thick but pourable dal with a creamy base and tender pieces.

What does panchmel dal mean?

The name means a mixture of five: “panch” means five, while “mel” refers to a mix or combination. You may also find it called panchratna dal, although recipes using either name can differ slightly.

Unlike a single-lentil dal, panchmel dal combines pulses that soften at different rates. Moong and masoor tend to break down readily, while chana dal holds its shape better. Together, they give you a fuller texture without cream or a separate thickener.

You don't need a fixed spice mixture. Some recipes use onion and tomato; others rely on cumin, asafoetida, ginger and dry spices. The five-dal mixture defines the dish, not a particular gravy base.

Which five lentils go into panchmel dal?

For a simple version, use the following five split dals. Check the form as well as the name when you buy them, since whole pulses and split dals don't cook in the same way.

  • Chana dal: Split, skinned Bengal gram gives you a firm bite and a mild, nutty flavour. Its yellow pieces are larger and rounder than the other dals in this mixture.
  • Toor dal: Also called arhar dal, split pigeon pea adds body and a slightly earthy flavour.
  • Moong dal: Split yellow moong softens easily and helps thicken the dal. Some household recipes use split green moong with its skin instead.
  • Masoor dal: Split red lentils break down as they cook and lose their orange-red colour as they soften.
  • Urad dal: Split, skinned white urad adds a creamy, slightly sticky texture. Use it in balance with the others so that it doesn't dominate the mixture.

Chana and toor are pulses, not true lentils in the botanical sense, but Indian cooking commonly groups all five under dal. When you shop for this dish, use the familiar dal names to find the right varieties.

What proportions should you use?

Start with equal quantities by dry volume. For a small household batch, use 2 tablespoons of each dal, giving you 10 tablespoons in total. You'll usually get about three moderate servings, depending on how much water you add and what else you serve.

Measure the dals before washing or soaking them. Equal proportions give you a useful starting point, but you can adjust them later: a little more chana gives you a firmer texture, while extra moong makes the mixture softer.

If you don't have one variety, you can still make a good mixed dal with the others, though four dals won't strictly make a five-dal mixture. To keep five varieties, you can replace yellow moong with split green moong, or white urad with split skin-on urad. Either substitution will change the colour and texture.

Don't replace a split dal with whole chickpeas or kidney beans in the same cooking cycle. You'll need to prepare and cook them differently, so they aren't direct substitutes here.

How do you cook the five dals together?

You can cook all five split dals together. A short soak helps the firmer chana dal soften more evenly alongside the quicker-cooking varieties.

  1. Check the dry dals for stones or other debris, then rinse them thoroughly in several changes of water.
  2. Soak the combined dals for about 30 to 60 minutes, then drain. If you skip soaking, allow more cooking time and check the chana dal carefully.
  3. Put the drained dals in a pressure cooker with roughly 3 parts fresh water to 1 part dry dal by volume. Add turmeric and salt.
  4. Pressure-cook according to your cooker's instructions until you can easily crush a piece of chana dal between a spoon and the side of the pot. Don't rely on a fixed whistle count, since cookers vary.
  5. Let the pressure release before opening the cooker, following the appliance instructions. Stir the dal and lightly mash a small portion, leaving plenty of pieces intact.
  6. Add hot water if needed, then simmer with the prepared tempering until the flavours combine. Stir along the bottom to prevent sticking.

If you're using an open saucepan, start with more water and keep extra hot water ready. Simmer until every variety is tender. Don't stop as soon as the moong and masoor have broken down; check the chana dal to judge whether the mixture is fully cooked.

How do you temper panchmel dal?

For the small batch above, start with about 1 tablespoon of ghee, ½ teaspoon cumin seeds, a pinch of asafoetida and 1 teaspoon finely chopped ginger. Heat the ghee, let the cumin sizzle, then briefly fry the asafoetida and ginger without burning them. You can also add garlic and chopped green chilli.

If you want onion and tomato, add a small chopped onion after the cumin and cook until soft. Then add a small chopped tomato and cook until it loses its raw smell. Add ground coriander and chilli powder to taste. To stop the ground spices from scorching, lower the heat and add a splash of water before stirring in the cooked dal.

Aim for a thick dal that you can ladle easily, not a dry mash or a watery broth. You should still notice tender chana pieces in the softer dal. Add lemon juice towards the end if you want a little sharpness, and finish with chopped coriander.

Serve it with baati, roti, plain rice or jeera rice. If you're serving it with baati, keep the dal loose enough to soak into the broken pieces. It thickens as it stands, so stir in a little hot water and check the salt before serving it again.